• Member Dashboard
  • Courses
  • E-Books
  • Consultations
  • Templates
  • Webinars
  • Ask a Question
  • Forums
  • Member Support
  • Login

Legal to English

Protect Your Business for Growth

  • About
  • Guides to Help You Better Understand Legal
    • Guide to Your Legal Foundation
    • Guide to Intellectual Property
    • Guide to Understanding Contracts
  • Podcast
You are here: Home / Articles / Intellectual Property / Copyright / Avoiding Copyright Infringement

Avoiding Copyright Infringement

Last week, we talked about derivative works and how to avoid accidentally creating a derivative work when you are creating a new product for your business. As I mentioned last week, even if you avoid the creation of a derivative work, you may still run into an issue of creating an “infringing work”. This is a more common type of claim for new intellectual property created after an original work is created. The issue being that that the author of the product that came first claims your new product infringes on their copyright

If the creator of a work that came before yours were to claim infringement on their copyright, they would need to prove the following:

  • Originality of the Work – They must prove there are not a large number of other, similar, works out there.
  • Access to the copyrighted work – They must prove that you had access to their copyrighted work.
  • Probative Similarities between the two works – They must prove in addition to the above points that the works are, in fact, similar.

To avoid this, you need to look at each of the factors before you create your work to make sure you are not, in fact, infringing on a work that came before yours. Because you commonly have access to the original work, when you are creating a new product to serve a market already served by an existing product, it is only necessary to look at the other two elements of any potential copyright claim brought against your new work.

The first is that certain components of the work are not original. Much like all phone books list names alphabetically by last name, some components may be the only logical way to display the information in your new product, which is the reason it is similar to the existing work (and potentially in other similar works). That would make the particular pieces not original. Put another way, it may be like elements in a novel. Depending on the genre, there are certain elements that are similar in each novel written. Those elements are not owned by any one author. It is the expression of those elements that is protected. The same would be true for your new product. Your expression of the idea is your property, just as the existing work’s expression is theirs.

The second issue will be “Probative Similarity” between the two works. This is where you differentiate yourself from other products on the market. Even if some elements of the products are similar because they are the only logical expression of a particular idea, you want to make your new product different from any other product on the market. This is both good business, and necessary to avoid any claims for infringement. The differences are where the true defenses lie. If you can show that your new product is not similar to an already existing work and that any similarities are not original expressions of an idea, you should be able to protect against any claims of infringement on your new product.

Much like we discussed last week, avoiding infringement comes from innovation. Creating something new. Though you may look at other products in your research, you do not want to simply create a different version of an already existing product. Even if you think the version is better. You want to create something new. Something different. In some cases, especially when it comes to intellectual property products, there will be similarities in the products because of the needs and desires of the market. It is how you approach the solution that will ensure you have a product that will change your industry, but will also be protected from any claims of infringement from those upset of your market disruption.

I will talk to you next week, unless you talk to me first 😉

Josh

Helping You Sleep at Night Knowing Your Business is Protected. Legally.

Even if you have been in business for years and everything has been fine. It can all change. Fast. And you could lose it all. If you don’t know how to protect yourself.

After working with entrepreneurs for years, I realized that many entrepreneurs have the same legal questions. And the same problems. Many entrepreneurs, though they understand that legal is an important part of protecting your business, just put it off. You always think you can do it later. Until there isn’t a later.

Want to know a better way to do legal?

Join Today for Free

Take the Conversation Further

Let's continue the conversation! Join me on Twitter or Facebook to join the conversation now!

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

About Josh

I am a business lawyer who helps small business owners and entrepreneurs develop a clear legal plan to protect their business as it grows. I podcast, blog, and spend my time giving entrepreneurs a clear path to legal protection. Growing your business can only happen if you have a firm foundation.

If you want to know more about how to build a business while laying your legal foundation of protection, you are in the right place. Read More…

Looking for Something?

Free Membership

Are you plagued by legal questions? Do you want to know how to protect your money, but don't want to spend the time (or money) trying to find a lawyer to ask a simple question?

Are you tired of "It Depends"?
 
Learn more about getting clear answers in an "it depends" world. Discover a Better Way to Do Legal.
 
Join Today for Free

Let’s Connect!

  • Facebook
  • Twitter

Legal to English Podcast

Entrepreneur Interviews

8 episodes

Legal to English

52 episodes

Don’t Miss Anything

Free Legal. Right to Your Inbox

Free Legal. No Spam. Unsubscribe Anytime.

Check Out Some Other Articles

More Than One Way to Skin a Cat – Negotiating Contracts

Everything is negotiable. That is one of the first things I learned in law school. It is one of the first things you learn in business. Everything is negotiable. Of course, that doesn’t mean you will always get what you want in your contracts. It doesn’t mean you can convince iTunes to sell you that HD […]

Contracts – Terms and Termination

Contracts are the backbone of business. Contracts describe relationships. Contracts outline how you are to be paid and what you must do for that money. They also should talk about how long the relationship should last. There is also a podcast episode on this topic. Contracts don’t last forever. At least they shouldn’t. Why is it […]

Legal to English Dictionary: Registered Agent

Legal A person or entity authorized to accept service of process for an entity. English The registered agent is a requirement in the Articles of Incorporation for an entity. A person or entity must be listed as the agent who will receive service of process (a lawsuit) for the entity. In many cases this is […]

The Best Way to Protect Your Idea – It’s Not an NDA

If you have been around the startup world for long, you have seen a Nondisclosure Agreement (NDA). You have either been asked to sign one, or you have asked someone to sign one. This is one of the most overused, least understood contracts in the startup world. Everyone thinks that their idea is the next […]

Negotiating Commercial Leases

At some point in the life of most businesses, you will need to rent some space. That means  you will have to read a commercial lease. Commercial leasing is different than renting an apartment or a house. The relationship between a landlord and a commercial tenant are quite different than its residential counterpart. Today, let’s […]

  • Fees and Credits
  • Privacy Policy
  • User Agreement
  • FAQs
  • Terms of Use

© 2013-2021, The Outsourced Associate LLC, Some Rights Reserved

Privacy Policy

This website or its third-party tools use cookies which are necessary to its functioning and required to improve your experience. By clicking the consent button, you agree to allow the site to use, collect and/or store cookies.
Please click the consent button to view this website.
I accept
Deny cookies Go Back